7 Investment Factors That Distinguish Investing Vs. Speculating

People easily confusing investing and speculating but there are key differences. Learn seven factors that distinguish between the two when making investment decisions.
Our articles, research studies, tools, and reviews maintain strict editorial integrity; however, we may be compensated when you click on or are approved for offers from our partners.

Investing entails the acceptance of risk in the pursuit of a worthwhile return. Speculation involves the same thing, and that commonality often leads people to confuse investing and speculation. In fact though, they are very different things, and if you are to become a successful investor, it is important to be able to distinguish the two.

Investing vs. speculation

Here are some of the things that distinguish investing from speculation:

1. In-depth information

Successful investors thoroughly research their targets, whether they be companies, government bond issues, or commodities. They understand the supply and demand dynamics that will drive market growth, and they understand the competitive forces and cost factors that will determine the ability to profit from that growth.

Speculators, on the other hand, don’t look in depth at the underlying vehicle, but simply put their money on a belief that it will go up or down.

2. A detailed outlook on the future

Understanding current conditions is good, but a further step entails being able to make some calculations about how those conditions will develop in the months and years ahead. This may take the form of things like a multi-year earnings projection for a stock, or quantifying the interest rate sensitivity of a bond.

You need to have thought through both what you expect to happen and how your investment will react if you are right. Without specifying how you will succeed, you are just speculating that things will work out in your favor.

3. Consider valuation

Taking into account valuation is a critical component of investing. It means comparing the price now with the likely future value of the investment based on its underlying fundamentals. This is critical, because markets often anticipate the future. If what you pay for an investment already reflects an assumption of its future success, there will be little upside for you even if things go in your favor.

On the other hand, speculators just hope that if things go well, the price will go up.

4. A flexible time frame

True investments can take some time to succeed – economic fundamentals usually evolve gradually, and sometimes it takes markets a while to recognize value. Having the flexibility to wait for all of this to play out increases your chance of success. In contrast, narrowing down the time frame in which it can happen takes you down the road towards guesswork.

5. An awareness of a differing perspective

Understanding how your view of an investment differs from the market consensus is very important, because if you don’t see things differently, there is less potential for you to profit. This is why buying into highly-popular investments takes on an increasing element of speculation. You haven’t really thought through why the investment should go up any further, you just like what everybody else likes.

Your differing perspective can involve any or all of the things discussed above: the information you have, your outlook on the future, valuation, or the time frame over which you are willing to hold onto the investment.

6. Recognition of the downside

Speculators tend to be focused primarily on the rewards of winning. But a true investor also understands the probability and downside potential of being wrong.

7. Extent of reliance on others

The “greater fool theory” means that you don’t care if you overpay for an investment, because if it keeps going up a greater fool will come along and pay you more for it. Depending on the irrationality of others rather than on investment fundamentals is one of the hallmarks of speculation.

Investing vs. safekeeping

Though true investing should be less of a risky proposition than speculation, it is important to understand the distinction between investing and safekeeping. Investing involves being conscious of the risk of loss, and trying to manage it in proportion with the potential upside. Safekeeping involves eliminating the risk of loss, at the expense of any real upside.

For example, savings accounts and other insured deposits should be fully protected against loss, but they offer little in the way of upside – especially when interest rates are low. However, if safekeeping is what you want, it is important to recognize that as your priority and ensure that your money is placed accordingly. This means making sure you stay within FDIC insurance limits, and not mistaking truly safe vehicles for somewhat low-risk investments, like government bonds for example, which still carry some risk of loss.

The distinction between investing and safekeeping is in the trade-off between potential upside and potential loss. The distinction between investing and speculation is essentially the difference between making a reasoned business decision and placing a bet.

More from MoneyRates.com:

How investors can identify stock market cycles

3 investment risk challenges in the modern age

How to approach investments in a sideways stock market

About Author
Richard Barrington has been a Senior Financial Analyst for MoneyRates. He has appeared on Fox Business News and NPR, and has been quoted by the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, USA Today, CNBC and many other publications. Richard has over 30 years of experience in financial services. He has earned the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation from the Association of Investment Management and Research (now the “CFA Institute”).