CD vs. high-yield savings account: What’s the difference?
Certificates of deposit (CDs) and high-yield savings accounts let you earn interest on your money without taking on stock market risk. However, high-yield savings accounts are typically better for money you might need to access, whereas CDs can make sense when you want to lock in a fixed interest rate for a set period.
Both options offer federal deposit insurance when held at federally insured banks or credit unions, subject to coverage limits, but they differ in how interest rates work and how easily you can access your money. This guide compares CDs and high-yield savings accounts, explains their pros and cons, and helps you decide which option makes the most sense for your savings goals.
CDs vs. high-yield savings accounts: At a glance
CDs and high-yield savings accounts both let you earn interest on your money, but they have differences. These include how their interest rates work, how easily you can access your savings, and whether you can add money to your account over time.
Here’s a quick look at how they compare.
| Feature | CDs | High-yield savings accounts |
|---|---|---|
| Interest rate | Usually fixed for the CD term, although some offer variable rates | Variable rates that can change at any time |
| Access to money | Money is typically held until maturity, with penalties for early withdrawals | Withdraw money as needed, although bank limits may apply |
| Adding money | Usually requires a single deposit when opening the account | Make additional deposits whenever you want |
| Account term | Set term ranging from a few months to several years | No set term or maturity date |
| Minimum deposit | Varies by bank and account | Varies by bank and account |
| Deposit insurance | Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (FDIC) or National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) insurance at eligible institutions | Same FDIC or NCUA insurance coverage |
| Best for | Savings goals with a set timeline and locking in a fixed interest rate | Emergency funds and savings you may need to access |
A CD may be a better choice if you know when you’ll need your money and want to lock in a fixed interest rate until then. A high-yield savings account offers more flexibility, making it a good option for emergency savings or money you may need on short notice.
How a high-yield savings account works
A high-yield savings account works like a traditional savings account, but it typically pays a higher interest rate. These accounts are often offered by online banks and credit unions, and they can help you earn more interest on your savings without locking up your money.
One important difference between high-yield savings accounts and CDs is that high-yield savings accounts have variable interest rates. This means your bank can raise or lower your annual percentage yield (APY) at any time, which can affect how much interest you earn.
High-yield savings accounts also offer more flexibility than CDs. You can typically make deposits whenever you want and withdraw money as needed. The Federal Reserve removed the federal six-withdrawal-per-month limit in 2020, although individual banks and credit unions can still set their own withdrawal limits or charge fees.
Before opening an account, watch for monthly maintenance fees, minimum balance requirements, and promotional interest rates that may expire. It’s also worth checking how long transfers take, especially if you plan to keep your savings at a different bank than your checking account.
Comparing the best high-yield savings accounts can help you find an option with a competitive APY, low fees, and easy access to your money.
How a CD works
A CD is a savings product that lets you earn interest on money you agree to leave in the bank or credit union for a set period. When you open a CD, you typically make a single deposit and lock in a fixed interest rate for the entire term, which can range from a few months to several years.
One of the main benefits of a traditional CD is knowing what interest rate you’ll earn until the account matures. However, you typically cannot withdraw your money early without paying a penalty.
There are also several types of CDs to consider:
- Traditional CDs: These typically offer a fixed interest rate and charge a penalty if you withdraw money before maturity.
- No-penalty CDs: These CDs let you withdraw your money early without a penalty, subject to the institution’s withdrawal rules.
- Bump-up CDs: These let you request a higher interest rate during your CD term if the bank raises rates, subject to certain restrictions.
- Brokered CDs: These CDs are purchased through brokerage firms instead of directly from banks. Certain brokered CDs are callable, which means the issuing bank can redeem them before their maturity date. Selling a brokered CD before maturity can also result in a loss.
CD early withdrawal penalties and maturity rules
Most traditional CDs charge an early withdrawal penalty if you take money out before the term ends. These penalties are typically based on a certain number of days or months of interest, although the exact amount depends on the bank and CD terms. A penalty can reduce or even wipe out the interest you’ve earned and may reduce your principal.
When your CD reaches its maturity date, you can typically withdraw your money or move it into another account without a penalty. However, many CDs automatically renew for another term unless you take action.
Banks often provide a short grace period after maturity when you can withdraw your funds, change your CD term or close the account without paying an early withdrawal penalty. Be sure to check your bank’s renewal policies and grace period before opening a CD.
You can compare the best CD rates to find options with competitive APYs, reasonable early withdrawal penalties and terms that match your savings goals.
Are you making these CD errors?
CD vs. high-yield savings rates: How rate changes affect your earnings
One of the biggest differences between CDs and high-yield savings accounts is how they respond to changing interest rates. Most CDs have fixed rates that stay the same until maturity, while high-yield savings accounts have variable rates that can rise or fall over time.
Here’s how changing interest rates can affect your savings:
- If interest rates fall: A fixed-rate CD keeps earning the same rate until maturity, even if banks start offering lower rates on new accounts. However, the APY on a high-yield savings account could drop, reducing how much interest you earn.
- If interest rates rise: A high-yield savings account may offer a higher APY if your bank increases its rate. With a traditional fixed-rate CD, your original rate stays the same until maturity.
Neither option is necessarily better in every situation. A CD offers more certainty about how much interest you’ll earn, while a high-yield savings account gives you the flexibility to benefit from potential rate increases.
CD vs. high-yield savings: Which account type should you choose?
Deciding between a CD and a high-yield savings account comes down to when you’ll need your money and how much flexibility you want.
Consider a high-yield savings account if:
- You’re building an emergency fund and need access to your money at any time.
- You’re saving for a goal but aren’t sure when you’ll need the money.
- You want to make regular deposits and build your savings over time.
- You want the opportunity to earn more interest if savings account rates rise.
Consider a CD if:
- You’re saving for a specific expense with a known date, such as a tuition payment or planned purchase.
- You have money you’re confident you won’t need until the CD matures.
- You want to lock in a fixed interest rate for a set period.
- You prefer knowing how much interest your savings will earn if you leave the money in the account until maturity.
Before choosing either option, compare APYs, minimum deposit requirements, and account fees. For CDs, pay close attention to the term length, early withdrawal penalties, automatic renewal policies, and grace periods. You should also confirm that your bank or credit union is federally insured.
How to combine high-yield savings with a CD ladder
You don’t necessarily have to choose between a CD and a high-yield savings account.
For example, you could keep your emergency fund in a high-yield savings account while putting money for planned future expenses into CDs. This lets you keep some savings accessible while locking in rates on money you won’t need right away.
Another option is to build a CD ladder by opening several CDs with different maturity dates. You can even use a CD ladder calculator to estimate your earnings over time. As each CD matures, you can withdraw the money or reinvest it based on your needs.
Just remember that CDs and savings accounts held at the same insured bank under the same ownership category share the same $250,000 FDIC insurance limit. This means your balances are combined when determining how much of your money is covered. Coverage is generally $250,000 per depositor, per insured institution, per ownership category.
You can also look into money market accounts, which offer another way to earn interest while keeping your savings accessible. These accounts typically have variable interest rates like high-yield savings accounts, but some also offer check-writing privileges or debit card access for added flexibility.
Frequently asked questions
CDs held at federally insured banks or credit unions are protected up to applicable deposit insurance limits. However, withdrawing money early could trigger a penalty that reduces your interest earnings or even cuts into your original deposit.
A no-penalty CD may be a better choice if you want to lock in an interest rate while keeping the option to withdraw your money early. However, high-yield savings accounts offer more flexibility for making additional deposits and withdrawals.
Yes, interest earned from CDs and high-yield savings accounts is generally taxed as ordinary income at the federal level. You typically need to report the interest you earn on your tax return, even if you leave the money in the account.
It depends on how much more interest you could earn and the early withdrawal penalty your bank charges. Compare the potential extra earnings with the penalty to determine whether switching accounts would be worth it.