Saving vs. investing: What’s the difference?
Saving and investing are related concepts, but there are important differences. They can each play a useful role in your personal finances, depending on your goals and when you’ll need the money.
Saving money can be a starting point toward building wealth. Having savings in the bank can prepare you for upcoming needs and emergencies.
Investing, meanwhile, offers the potential for higher longer-term returns but carries the risk of losing money.
Because saving and investing serve different purposes, figuring out how much of each you need starts with identifying your goals. Here’s how to decide when to save, when to invest, and how the two can work together.
Key difference: Saving keeps money safe in federally insured accounts for near-term needs, offering modest interest with no risk to principal. Investing pursues higher long-term returns by buying assets like stocks and bonds, but carries the risk of market losses.
Saving vs. investing at a glance
What’s the difference between saving and investing? Here’s how they compare:
| Saving | Investing | |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | Keep money safe and available for near-term goals. Earn interest over time to help cover a wider range of upcoming needs. | Pursue long-term growth through investment returns, with the risk of loss. |
| Typical products | · Bank or credit union savings accounts | · Individual stocks |
| · High-yield savings accounts | · Bonds | |
| · Money market accounts | · Mutual funds | |
| · Certificates of deposit (CDs) | · Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) | |
| Risk to principal | Your money can be 100% protected if it falls within the limits of federal deposit insurance. This can cover up to $250,000 per depositor in eligible products at participating banks and credit unions. | Risk varies according to the type of investments but can be considerable. This includes the possibility of significant volatility from year-to-year and the risk of permanent losses. |
| Return potential | Earn interest at a variable rate or, with most CDs, a fixed rate for a specified term. | Potential for higher long-term returns, but returns aren’t guaranteed and depend on market conditions and the investments selected. |
| Main risk | Inflation can erode purchasing power if savings interest doesn’t keep pace with rising prices. | Market declines and permanent investment losses. |
| Protection available | Federal deposit insurance can protect your savings as long as they fit within its guidelines. | No protection against market losses. SIPC may protect eligible customer assets if a member brokerage fails. |
| Time horizon | Emergency funds and goals within approximately five years. | Long-term goals, such as retirement, depending on risk tolerance. |
Saving fundamentals: Stability, access, and trade-offs
The defining characteristics of savings are stability and access:
- Stability means using insured deposit accounts that protect your principal within coverage limits.
- Access means being able to withdraw funds when needed, although CDs generally require you to wait until maturity to avoid penalties.
The main trade-off for providing stability and access to your money is that savings products generally offer a lower rate of return than investments.
For example, savings and money market accounts typically offer easier access to your money than CDs. A CD may offer a competitive fixed rate, but withdrawing money before maturity generally triggers a penalty.
Savings interest is also generally taxable, and inflation can reduce your purchasing power if prices rise faster than your savings grow.
Federal deposit insurance
If you keep your savings at a bank or credit union, eligible deposits may be protected by federal deposit insurance.
Federal deposit insurance is provided by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (FDIC) for banks, and by the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) for federally insured credit unions. This insurance protects eligible deposits in the event that your bank or credit union fails.
For both FDIC and NCUA insurance, standard coverage is $250,000 per depositor, per insured institution, per ownership category. Savings accounts, money market accounts, CDs and checking accounts at insured banks and credit unions are covered. Your bank or credit union may offer other types of products that are not eligible for this insurance.
Understanding investing: Growth potential and market risks
Investing involves buying assets such as stocks and bonds that can go up or down in value. Some of these fluctuations may be temporary, but some losses can be permanent.
To some extent, diversification can help you manage risk. Diversification is the practice of spreading your money across many different investments that perform differently from one another, so they don’t all rise or fall at the same time. This strategy helps reduce the impact of losses in any single investment.
Investments generally offer greater long-term growth potential than savings accounts, but higher potential returns typically come with greater risk. Your investment choices should reflect your financial goals, time horizon, and tolerance for losses.
SIPC protection: What it covers and what it doesn’t
Eligible customer assets held at member brokerage firms may be protected by the Securities Investor Protection Corp. (SIPC). This provides up to $500,000 in protection per customer, including a $250,000 limit for cash claims, if the brokerage fails and customer assets are missing.
SIPC protection only restores the value of customer holdings if a brokerage firm fails. It does not protect against losses from market declines.
Should you save or invest first?
When you want to figure out how much you should have in savings and how much you should invest, it helps to think of it in terms of a timeline for when you’ll need the money.
Because savings are readily available, either immediately or in the near future, they’re generally better suited for money that you anticipate needing within the next few years. This may also include setting aside an emergency fund for unexpected needs.
For needs that are several years away, investing can be a way to pursue long-term growth, depending on your risk tolerance.
A practical approach is to:
- Build an emergency fund in an accessible, federally insured account.
- Consider paying down high-interest debt, which can otherwise offset the benefits of saving or investing.
- Set aside money for upcoming expenses and other near-term goals.
- Consider investing for longer-term goals once you have a financial cushion.
These priorities can overlap. For example, you might contribute to a workplace retirement plan while continuing to build emergency savings.
How to choose between saving and investing for different goals
Below is an example of how you can match your savings and investment choices to when you’ll need the money:
| Goal | Timeframe | Financial products |
|---|---|---|
| Build an emergency fund | Anytime | High-yield savings or money market account |
| Buy a new car | 3 to 5 years | Savings accounts or CDs that mature before the planned purchase |
| Fund a child's future college education | 5 to 15 years | Depending on how close your child is to college age, this may involve a mix of savings and investments. |
| Retirement savings | 20 to 30 years | Long-term investments selected according to your goals and risk tolerance. |
You may have additional goals that you’d want to fit into a similar timeline. In each case, the timeframe should help guide the type of financial products you use to meet those goals. Once you estimate how much money you’ll need for each goal, you’ll have targets for how much to put into savings and investments.
Frequently asked questions about saving and investing
This depends on your situation. Think about any significant expenses you have coming up. Also, look at your normal monthly expenses, and set aside enough money to cover those expenses should you lose your current source of income. Once you have enough savings to cover three to six months of normal expenses, plus any large expenses you anticipate over the next couple years, you should be in good shape to start investing.
No, you cannot lose money in a savings account covered by FDIC or NCUA insurance, as long as your deposits remain within coverage limits. To verify your savings are protected: (1) confirm your institution is FDIC- or NCUA-insured, (2) ensure the product type is eligible (savings, money market, checking, or CD account), and (3) check that your combined deposits do not exceed the $250,000 per depositor, per institution, per ownership category limit. Finally, make sure your combined deposits fall within the applicable insurance limits. Standard coverage is $250,000 per depositor, per insured institution, per ownership category. Joint accounts and certain other ownership categories may qualify for separate coverage.
High-yield savings accounts and CDs are generally considered savings products rather than market investments. They earn interest on your deposits, and eligible balances are federally insured within applicable limits. Unlike stocks or investment funds, they don’t offer returns tied to market performance.
No. Investments held in brokerage accounts, including stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, aren’t FDIC-insured. However, uninvested cash swept into an FDIC-insured bank may qualify for deposit insurance, depending on the brokerage cash management program and applicable coverage requirements.