Credit Union vs Bank: Which Offers Better Rates and Service in 2025?

The choice between credit unions vs banks matters more than ever for your financial health, but what is a credit union vs bank? With approximately 4,645 credit unions and 4,614 banks vying for your business, understanding their key differences can significantly impact your wallet.

Credit unions consistently offer better rates on deposits and savings. The average one-year CD pays 3.26% at credit unions compared to just 2.41% at banks as of September 2024. This advantage extends to loans, too, where the average 60-month new car loan costs 6.27% at credit unions versus 7.50% at banks.

Are credit unions better than banks for your specific situation? The answer depends on what you value most, including higher interest rates on savings, lower fees, personalized customer service, or cutting-edge technological features.

This guide breaks down the key differences between these financial institutions to help you make the best choice for your money in 2025. We’ll examine fee structures, interest rates, accessibility features, and membership requirements to give you a complete picture of both options.

Fee Structures Compared: Credit Unions vs Banks

The fee differences between credit unions and banks can significantly impact your financial health. Understanding these charges and the impact of lower interest rates helps you choose the institution that best aligns with your banking habits and priorities.

Monthly maintenance fees: $0–$10 vs $5–$25

Credit unions typically charge $0–$10 for checking account maintenance, while traditional banks often impose higher fees ranging from $5–$25. Credit unions also provide more accessible paths to waive these fees than banks. You may avoid these charges by maintaining minimum balances, enrolling in direct deposits, or using paperless statements.

Overdraft charges: $26.61 vs $31.24 average

Credit unions demonstrate their member-first approach with lower overdraft penalties. The average overdraft fee at credit unions is $26.61, less than the $31.24 average at banks. A recent CFPB rule aims to curb excessive overdraft fees, potentially saving Americans up to $5 billion annually.

ATM fees: network access vs out-of-network costs

Credit unions counterbalance their smaller individual networks through smart cooperative arrangements. Many participate in the CO-OP Shared Branch network, giving members access to over 30,000 surcharge-free ATMs nationwide. Meanwhile, out-of-network ATM fees reached a record high in 2024, with Americans paying an average of $4.77 per transaction. Many credit unions offer monthly ATM fee reimbursements ranging from $10 to $20, which is particularly valuable for frequent travelers.

Hidden charges: paper statements, transfers, and more

Less obvious fees can accumulate quickly. Paper statement fees typically range from $1 to $3 monthly at both institutions. However, credit unions often take a more transparent approach to these charges. Beginning December 2024, some credit unions have implemented a $2 monthly paper statement fee to offset rising processing costs. Meanwhile, regulators have flagged multiple non-sufficient funds representment fees—charging repeatedly when the same check bounces—as potentially unfair practices.

Bank vs Credit Union Interest Rates on Deposits and Loans

The interest rate gap between credit unions and banks stands out as one of the most compelling reasons to consider switching financial institutions. Credit unions consistently provide more favorable terms across virtually all deposit and loan products.

Savings Account Yields: 3.26% vs 2.41% (2024 Q3)

Interest rates on deposit accounts favor credit union members. The national average for a one-year certificate of deposit (CD) with a $10,000 deposit reaches 3.26% at credit unions compared to just 2.41% at banks. This pattern holds even as the national average savings account yield across all institutions hovers around 0.59%. This difference adds up to substantially higher earnings over time for savers looking to maximize returns.

CD Rates: Higher Returns at Credit Unions

The yield advantage extends across all CD maturity periods. Credit unions outperform banks at every term length, with particularly notable differences in longer-term products:

• 5-year CDs: 2.93% at credit unions versus 2.05% at banks
• 3-year CDs: 2.85% at credit unions versus 2.00% at banks
• 6-month CDs: 2.86% at credit unions versus 2.07% at banks

Loan Rates: 6.27% vs 7.50% for Auto Loans

On the lending side, credit unions maintain their competitive edge. New car loans with 48-month terms average 6.27% at credit unions compared to 7.13% at banks. The gap widens for used vehicles, with 48-month loans averaging 6.46% at credit unions versus 7.51% at banks. Many credit unions further enhance these advantages through member-specific discounts.

Credit Card APRs: 11.5% vs 15.9% Averages

The disparity in credit card rates may be most striking. The CFPB reports that the 25 largest credit card issuers charge interest rates 8–10 percentage points higher than small banks and credit unions. The average classic credit card APR at credit unions is 12.86%, substantially lower than the 15.29% average at banks. This difference could save the typical cardholder $400–$500 annually in interest charges.

Access, Technology, and Membership Requirements: Credit Union Versus Bank

Beyond rates and fees, the accessibility features of credit unions vs banks differ in practical ways that impact your day-to-day banking experience.

Branch and ATM Access: 30,000+ CO-OP ATMs vs Bank Networks

Credit unions have traditionally operated fewer individual branches than banks. However, they’ve overcome this limitation through the CO-OP Shared Branch network, which provides members access to more than 30,000 surcharge-free ATMs nationwide. Additionally, credit unions offer access to over 6,000 shared branches coast-to-coast, forming a network larger than most big banks. This cooperative approach allows credit unions to compete with larger institutions despite having fewer proprietary locations.

Mobile App Quality: Slight Edge to Banks

Digital banking capabilities typically favor traditional banks. The disparity shows in adoption rates, with banks reaching 27% mobile banking enrollment compared to credit unions’ 12.6%. Banks between $1–10 billion in assets have achieved 27.3% annual growth in mobile banking usage since Q2 2013, while credit unions in the same category report 21.2% growth.

Though credit unions were earlier adopters of mobile banking across all asset segments, banks have invested more heavily in user experience and functionality. Large banks frequently dedicate substantial resources to developing advanced features like quick balance checks without logging in, real-time fraud alerts, and integrated investment tools.

Membership Eligibility: Field of Membership vs Open Access

The most fundamental difference lies in accessibility requirements. While anyone can open an account at most banks, credit unions operate under membership eligibility restrictions. Credit unions organize around a “field of membership” (FOM) that falls into three categories:

• Occupational: members working for the same employer or in the same profession
• Associational: members belonging to the same church, professional group, or civic organization
• Community: members living, working, worshiping, or attending school in the same geographic area

Nevertheless, numerous credit unions have expanded eligibility through minimal requirements, often allowing anyone to join by donating to an affiliated foundation.

Are Credit Unions Better Than Banks for You?

Your ideal financial institution depends entirely on your personal priorities and banking habits. The data reveals clear patterns about which option might best serve your specific needs.

Why are Credit Unions Better Than Banks for Some Accounts?

Credit unions aren’t better than banks, but they deliver clear advantages if you prioritize personalized service and lower costs. According to the Credit Union National Association, their not-for-profit structure creates tangible financial benefits, with members receiving value equivalent to $179 per person or $376 per household annually.

If building savings or managing debt tops your priority list, credit unions typically offer significantly higher interest rates on deposits and lower rates on loans. This advantage is particularly notable for auto financing, where rates average 6.27% at credit unions compared to banks’ 7.50%.

Credit unions also stand out for community involvement. As member-owned institutions, they focus on local initiatives and democratic governance—each member gets one vote regardless of deposit size.

Banks vs credit unions: When a bank might be a better fit

Banks offer distinct benefits for those who value technological innovation and nationwide accessibility. If you travel frequently or conduct international business, traditional banks provide more extensive branch networks and typically better foreign transaction capabilities. They also tend to introduce new apps and digital features more rapidly.

Additionally, banks may better serve your needs if you require specialized financial products or investment options beyond basic accounts. Their profit-driven structure often enables them to offer more diverse services, including investment services and higher loan limits.

Online Banks: A Third Option to Consider

Online-only banks present a compelling middle ground, often combining credit unions’ favorable rates with banks’ technological capabilities. Without physical branches, these institutions typically deliver higher savings account yields, sometimes exceeding traditional banks and credit unions.

Tech-savvy customers who rarely need face-to-face service will find online banks particularly suitable. Many provide fee-free ATM networks and 24/7 customer support via phone or chat. These features make them ideal if you value convenience and competitive rates above in-person relationships.

Credit Unions vs Banks at a Glance

The table below summarizes key differences between credit unions and banks, making it easier to compare their features side by side.

This comparison highlights the substantial differences in rates and fees between credit unions and banks. While credit unions excel in offering lower costs and higher yields, banks generally provide better technological features, more branches, and broader accessibility.

Is a Credit Union Better Than a Bank? It Depends on You

The choice between credit unions and banks comes down to what matters most for your financial goals. Throughout this comparison, we’ve seen credit unions consistently deliver higher deposit rates and lower loan rates. Their member-first approach provides real benefits worth hundreds of dollars annually per household.

However, banks offer distinct advantages for customers who prioritize advanced digital features and widespread branch availability. The 2025 banking landscape shows both institutions adapting to changing consumer needs, though credit unions maintain their edge in customer satisfaction scores.

The benefits of a credit union vs bank depend on your specific priorities:

• If you value community connection, personalized service, and cost savings, credit unions offer clear advantages
• If you need cutting-edge technology, diverse financial products, or extensive branch networks, traditional banks might better serve your needs

Online banks present a compelling third option. They combine favorable rates without branch overhead costs while delivering strong technological capabilities. These digital-first institutions often appeal to customers seeking competitive rates and convenient digital access.

Credit unions and banks continue evolving to meet modern financial demands despite their differences. The decision between them remains personal, but with this 2025 guide, you can make an informed choice aligned with your unique financial goals.

The data clearly shows that understanding fee structures, interest rates, and accessibility features beforehand leads to better financial outcomes, regardless of your chosen institution type.

FAQs